F-O outlasted 13 other entrants to win the 2004 Lord of the Ring Match, earning himself a WAW Championship Match under any stipulation of his choosing at Legacy 2004. Below are the order of eliminations.
1. Ivanna eliminated herself
2. Benjamin Pride was eliminated by himself after suffering an injury
3. The Max was eliminated by numerous people
4. The Masked Referee was eliminated by Justin
5. Toxic was eliminated by Rocko
6. Puma was eliminated by Rocko
7. Ruckus was eliminated by Dirty Dealer
8. Dirty Dealer was eliminated by numerous people
9. Rocko eliminated himself after hitting himself with Frankie (now known as Trick)
10. Captain Amazing (Captain Vincent Zarrello) was eliminated by Major Morpheus Morency
11. Justin was eliminated by F-O
12. Freakin Flax was eliminated by Major Morpheus Morency
13. Major Morpheus Morency was eliminated by F-O
Q defeated Sin and The Jersey Devil in a 3-Man Sudden Death Match to retain the WAW Championship when Q pinned Sin after the return of Grave Digger saw 2 Headstones for Sin and The Jersey Devil, leading to Q's pin of Sin.