Karnage outlasted 18 other entrants to win the 2005 Lord of the Ring Match, earning himself a WAW Championship Match under any stipulation of his choice at Legacy 2005. Below are the order of eliminations.
1. Saige was eliminated by Sin
2. Dirty Dealer was eliminated by numerous participants
3. Jimmy Foxx was eliminated by Karnage
4. Skit was eliminated by Karnage
5. Paul Clement was eliminated by Karnage
6. Shanic was eliminated by Karnage
7. Vempriss was eliminated by Sin
8. Shats O'Bannigan was eliminated by Captain Vincent Zarrello
9. Barry Ace was eliminated by Joey Staplez
10. Joey Staplez was eliminated by Captain Vincent Zarrello
11. Captain Vincent Zarrello was eliminated by Rocko
12. B. Dizzle was eliminated by Craig Trace
13. Damian Darkside was eliminated by numerous participants)
14. Craig Trace was eliminated by outside interference from Damian Darkside
15. Todd Sople was eliminated by Asylum's Rocko and Mr. Psycho
16. Mr. Psycho was eliminated by Rocko
17. Rocko was eliminated by Sin
18. Sin was eliminated by Karnage
The Big Top Playaz (F-O & Puma) defeated Heaven Burning (Sick & The Jersey Devil) in the finals of the WAW Team Championship Tournament to become the first WAW Team Champions since 2001 when Puma pinned The Jersey Devil after a Playa Hater.
Grave Digger (Gino Diomedes) defeated Freakin Flax in an Obstacle Match to retain the WAW Championship when Grave Digger was the one to climb a ladder and obtain the WAW Championship.